Expert consensus comparison
Titleist Pro V1 vs Callaway Supersoft (2025)
Tour-ball control versus an everyday soft-feel distance ball, without pretending one ball fits every swing.
Titleist Titleist Pro V1 Golf Ball 9.0GolfTested score 
Callaway Callaway Supersoft Golf Balls (2025) 8.5GolfTested score Titleist Pro V1 Golf Ball scores 0.5 higher overall. Titleist Pro V1 Golf Ball leads 4 of 6 metrics, Callaway Supersoft Golf Balls (2025) leads 2. This is not presented as a GolfTested lab head-to-head.
Titleist Pro V1 Golf Ball
The balanced benchmark — low long-game spin, elite greenside control, and the trusted feel that serious golfers rely on.
Players who want tour-proven spin separation (low driver, high wedge) and reliable performance without surprises.
Beginners or high handicaps primarily seeking maximum distance on a budget, or those who prefer very soft feel.
See today's price at Amazon.
- Live price and stock on the listing
- Scored on the GolfTested rubric, not by the retailer
Links to Amazon may earn GolfTested a commission. It never changes a score.
Callaway Supersoft Golf Balls (2025)
A soft, easy-launch ball that makes everyday golf feel friendlier without giving up useful tee-shot speed.
Golfers who want soft feel, easy launch, and reliable value for regular rounds.
You already launch the ball high, need tour-level short-game spin, or prefer a firm, clicky feel.
See today's price at Amazon.
- Live price and stock on the listing
- Scored on the GolfTested rubric, not by the retailer
Links to Amazon may earn GolfTested a commission. It never changes a score.
Scorecard
Where the scores split
Gold marks the higher score in each row. Prices are brand-direct where we have checked them; Amazon prices are never printed.
Titleist Pro V1 Golf Ball
- Reformulated core delivers faster ball speed while maintaining signature low long-game spin
- Outstanding greenside spin and control for approach shots and short game
- Consistent flight and soft-yet-solid feel that pros and amateurs trust year after year
- Widely available with strong resale and performance across conditions
- Premium price compared to value-oriented or distance-focused balls
- Firmer feel than some ultra-soft options (not ideal for very slow swing speeds)
- Best results for mid-to-low handicaps; higher handicaps may see more benefit from higher-launch balls
Callaway Supersoft Golf Balls (2025)
- Soft feel is easy to like from the tee through the putting surface
- Straightforward launch and stable flight suit a wide range of everyday swings
- Strong value when you want a recognizable ball without tour-ball pricing
- A good visibility and feel option for golfers still building consistent contact
- Golfers who want a firmer, more explosive strike may find it too muted
- It is not the first choice for players chasing maximum wedge spin
- The soft cover can show scuffs after trees, cart paths, or aggressive practice
- A softer ball will not fix a launch or contact problem by itself